Neutral Eyebrow Pens

Sephora customers often prefer the following products when searching for Neutral Eyebrow Pens.

Achieve flawlessly defined brows that complement any look effortlessly, thanks to our selection of Neutral Eyebrow Pens. Perfect for creating natural-looking arches, these versatile tools offer precision and ease of use for both beginners and beauty enthusiasts alike. Whether you're aiming for a subtle enhancement or a bold statement, our range of neutral shades ensures a seamless match to your brow color and skin tone. Explore the collection to find your new go-to for beautifully sculpted brows every day.

Bobbi BrownPrecise 24-Hour Ultra Slim Waterproof Eyebrow Pencil

Size: 0.06g·ITEM: 2839876

Color: Neutral Blonde - cool light neutral grey​

161 Reviews

$25.00

Great eyebrows pencil...It’s like putting butter on your eyebrows and not on a bad way. I love a creamy eyebrow pencil, it’s the best thing you can find. ...The eyebrow pencil is applied softly and blends well.

What it is: An ultrafine brow pencil that delivers effortless precision, buildable color, and waterproof, 24-hour wear.


Ingredient Callouts: Free of parabens, formaldehydes, formaldehyde-releasing agents, phthalates, mineral oil, retinyl palmitate, oxybenzone, coal tar, hydroquinone, sulfates SLS & SLES, triclocarban, triclosan, and contains less than one percent synthetic fragrance. It is also gluten-free, cruelty-free, and comes in recyclable packaging.


What Else You Need to Know: This pencil has an angled, superfine tip that fills with hair-like strokes. The creamy formula glides on without tugging or breaking and delivers 24-hour wear with a fade-resistant, non-smudging finish.

Urban DecayBrow Blade 2-in-1 Eyebrow Pen + Waterproof Pencil

Size: .01 oz·ITEM: 2182350

Color: Neutral Nana - neutral brown

2.1K Reviews

$28.00

I like this product a lot, the colour is perfect, it doesn't rub off, however the pencil side lasted maybe a 1/5th of the time that the pen did. and the pen also did eventually start to leak which is a consistent issue I've noticed with eyebrow pens across brands. ...Can’t live without this, one of my favorite eyebrow pens because of the liquid pen! Excellent precision without looking like a crayon

What it is: A dual-ended ink stain and waterproof eyebrow pencil that fills and defines brows with microblade precision for up to 24 hours.


Ingredient Callouts: Free of sulfates SLS and SLES, parabens, and phthalates. This product is also cruelty-free.


What Else You Need to Know: The waterproof brow pencil shapes, shades, and fills in sparse brows while the brow pen's brush tip + ink stain mimics thin, hair-like strokes to add depth and dimension for a mir

SEPHORA COLLECTIONRetractable EyeBrow Pencil - Waterproof

Size: 0.003 oz/ 0.08 g·ITEM: 2377232

Color: 1.25 Neutral Gray Brown

4.5K Reviews

$15.00

GREAT EYEBROW PEN...I received this product as a free gift and I’m so happy with the formula, I can create my eyebrows in 5 minutes with a natural look. I love the different shades!...If you want high quality product with low price, you should definitely consider this eyebrow pen.

What it is: A retractable waterproof pencil with an ultra-fine tip that creates hair-like strokes for precise definition and long-lasting, natural-looking brows.

What Else You Need to Know: This brow pencil is great for filling in sparse areas, creating shape, and mimicking the look of actual brow hair. It is available in a range of natural-looking colors, and the long-wearing formula stays put and won’t smudge. A spoolie brush is also included so you can blend the product throughout your brows.

Clinical Results: In a satisfaction test performed on 21 volunteers:
- 90% of users said that the result stayed the same all day long
- 86% of users said that the eye pencil’s tip ensured precise application

SEPHORA COLLECTIONInsta-Brow Waxy Brow Pencil

Size: 0.007 Net Wt oz / 0.2 g·ITEM: 2525194

Color: 1.25 Neutral Gray Brown - light gray brown

757 Reviews

$15.00

I am loving this Insta brow waxy eyebrow pencil. It definitely helps highlight and shape my eyebrows. ...This waxy eyebrow pencil is a big winner!...Sephora has a hit with this great eyebrow product. I have dark brown hair and fair skin, my eyebrows are very faint and thin.

What it is: A waxy brow pencil with a lightweight, soft, conditioning texture that quickly shapes, fills, and tames brows for all-day wear.

Ingredient Callouts: Free of parabens.

What Else You Need to Know: A few swipes of this waxy brow pencil create fuller, immediately styled, and conditioned brows that stay in place all day. It provides a sheer, buildable tint of color for a natural look with a blade-shaped tip for easy-to-use, precise application. It is made without ingredients from animal origin.

ValentinoBrow Trio Eyebrow Liner

Size: 0.4 mL/ 0.14 g·ITEM: 2542272

Color: 01 Taupe - neutral blonde

109 Reviews

$40.00

Pen side is a must...Wish they would offer a pen only. The pen tip is very fine which works great on creating natural looking hairlike strokes. ...FAVORITE brow pen!...I have tried basically every eyebrow pen, pencils you name it. This is by far my favorite brow product.

What it is: A three-in-one long-wear liner that has a liquid-ink micro-liner to fill, eyebrow pencil to shade, and brow brush to blend and comb.

What Else You Need to Know: This liner has a hidden brow brush that blends, fluffs, combs, and shapes your eyebrows and a waterproof flat-tip eyebrow pencil that shades and fills in gaps where desired. It also has a sheer liquid-ink micro-liner that fills your brows precisely by creating realistic hair-like strokes for a natural, fuller result.

GucciGucci Crayon Définition Sourcils Eyebrow Pencil

Size: 0.04 oz/ 1.19 g·ITEM: 2356087

Color: 01 Taupe - gray blonde

84 Reviews

$33.00

Totally unnecessarily extravagant, any eyebrow pencil would likely work just as well as this one but if you prefer the look of pencil eyebrows and love luxury beauty this is a great choice. ...Gucci Eyebrow Pencil Taupe...I’m 51 with cool, blonde hair, and light, sparse eyebrows. This pencil is perfect. It’s the right color, not too warm or yellow.

What it is: Practically encased within a sleek, dual-sided pencil for easy application, this Gucci eyebrow pencil also features a spoolie that allows you to seamlessly blend the pigment into the eyebrows, effortlessly shaping and transforming them, leaving your brows with a flawless and defined finish. Available in six perfect shades, the buildable formula of this pencil enables you to experiment with anything from a subtle natural makeup look to an astonishingly bold statement brow that doesn’t bleed, transfer or budge.

MERITBrow 1990 Ultra Fine Eyebrow Gel Pencil

Size: 0.0007 oz / 0.02 g·ITEM: 2787109

Color: Brown Black - dark brown/black with warm undertones

357 Reviews

$24.00

I don’t have the best eyebrows but I love that this pencil in thin and draw in some nice eyebrow hairs. ...The gel pencil, I am able to draw in my eyebrows. Definitely worth a purchase.

What it is: An easy-to-use, microfine gel pencil that fills and defines brows for soft, natural-looking fullness.


Highlighted Ingredients: 

Sunflower oil: Rich in nourishing vitamin E and known to provide lightweight moisture.        

Safflower extract: Encourages softer, more supple hair.         

Hibiscus flower extract: Rich in amino acids to help condition hair. 


Ingredient Callouts: This product is vegan and cruelty-free.


What Else You Need to Know: Easy to apply and designed to be used only where needed, this micro pencil creates soft strokes to add natural-looking 

Charlotte TilburyBrow Cheat Refillable Hair-Like Eyebrow Pencil

Size: 0.003 oz/ 0.1 g·ITEM: 2432656

Color: Natural Brown - neutral undertones for dark blonde to medium brown and auburn brows

540 Reviews

$26.00

Amazing eyebrow pencil...This eyebrow product is amazing and it works incredibly I love how fine the precision tip is for feeling in your eyebrows and that made it a lot easier to use...Eyebrow pencil ...Love love this product since it my eyebrows have been looking on point. I have a scar on one of my eyebrows, and this is the only product that has made my eyebrows look like new again and natural

What it is: A refillable micro-precision pencil that mimics the micro-effect of real-life tiny hairs.

Highlighted Ingredients:
- Carnauba Wax: Gives stretch and elasticity to brow hairs for a smooth and creamy application.
- Micro-crystalline Wax: Helps the easy-to-use, blendable texture glide on.
- Pure Pigments: Create natural-looking color with depth and no ashy undertones.

Ingredient Callouts: Free of parabens, formaldehydes, formaldehyde-releasing agents, phthalates, mineral oil, retinyl palmitate, oxybenzone, coal tar, hydroquinone, sulfates SLS & SLES, triclocarban, triclosan, and contains less than one percent synthetic fragrance. It is also vegan, gluten-free, and cruelty-free.

Benefit CosmeticsMini Precisely, My Brow Pencil Waterproof Eyebrow Definer

Size: 0.001 / 0.04g·ITEM: 2305100

Color: Shade 2.75 - warm auburn

1.9K Reviews

$16.00

New neutrals!!...These new neutral colors are dopeeee! I always find the “medium brown” is too warm for my skin tone but the neutrals are great. ...Best eyebrow pencil ever. Gives the best natural looking and fuller eyebrows

What it is:
An ultra-fine brow shaping and defining pencil that draws incredibly natural hair-like strokes that last up to 12 hours.

What it does:
Transform shapeless, undefined brows with just a few strokes of Precisely, My Brow Pencil. The custom ultra-fine tip makes adding detailed definition to your brows easy, by drawing incredibly natural-looking, hair-like strokes that last up to 12 hours. This rich, waterproof pencil is ideal for spot filling sparse or over-tweezed areas and the smudge-proof formula is firm enough for precise application yet glides on effortlessly to bring symmetry to your brows and your entire face.

Products related to Neutral Eyebrow Pens

Professional Eyebrow Pencil
“I love how the pencil is angled and not to dark when applying so my eyebrows look natural. another plus about this pencil is the eyebrow gel on the other end which holds my eyebrows in place, when I dont use the gel my eyebrows tend to curl and look messy”
Controlled Application Eyebrow Pencils
“I was gifted this brow pencil complementary of Lawless beauty. Me personally I’m not a big fan of eyebrow pencils but I’ll make an exception for this one it actually works very well it took me a minute to get used to but it’s definitely a favorite”
Precision Eyebrow Brushes
“best brow brush I have ever tried speaking from a sensitive skin and eczema ridden person, its so gentle and doesn't irritate the skin under my brows and applies a generous amount of product. it may seem somewhat expensive but is worth it for the quality you're getting, the spoolie is also fairly large and larger than the anastasia and benefit brushes, so amazing for thicker and bushier eyebrows”
Light Brown Brow Pencil
“As a redhead whose hair has a lot of light brown undertones, I’ve struggled finding a brow pencil that matched my brows perfectly”
Honey Brown Eyebrow Pencils
“I've had other Anastasia eyebrow pencils but this one is by far my favorite”
Medium Brown Eyebrow Pencil
“I love this product. This is my favorite eyebrow pencil. I didnt like this color as much, as I previously had tried medium brown and I do like it better, but this one still works just as well and I am still going to use it”
Smooth Brow Products
“Now, I haven't replaced my other brow products with this. I still use my ABH brow wiz and several other brow products I love, but this has become one of my favorite brow products to my collection, LOL”
Best Brow Pencil
“Love this brow pencil! I've always enjoyed mechanical pencils for my brows, especially because they're almost always fine point.... so this is a big game changer for me already being so fine”
Thick Eyebrow Pencil
“I’ve probably tried all eyebrow pencils made and this is hands down the best i’ve tried”
Charcoal Eyebrow Pencil
“I’m 51 with cool, blonde hair, and light, sparse eyebrows. This pencil is perfect. It’s the right color, not too warm or yellow”